Safe Sleep | THIS IS FLORIDA
Back to sleep, a bare crib, room sharing, overheating, pacifiers and car seats, with each 1894 point checked against Safe to Sleep and the AAP.
Florida information in plain text. No need to ask AI.
What the 1894 book covers
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
The 1894 first edition has a short section on sleep in Part III, plus notes on the nursery, its temperature and airing in Part I. Each point below is labeled “Historical (1894)” and followed by “Today:” with guidance from NIH Safe to Sleep and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP).
Back to sleep
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Historical (1894): Holt says a child should not always sleep in the same position, but should be changed from side to side.
Today: Outdated and unsafe. NIH Safe to Sleep says to place babies on their backs to sleep for naps and at night, until they are 1 year old, including babies born early and babies with reflux. It is not safe to place babies on their sides or stomachs to sleep, not even for a nap. Babies who usually sleep on their backs but are placed on their stomach or side face a much higher SIDS risk. Once a baby can roll both ways on their own, you can leave them in the position they choose after starting on their back.
The crib and the sleep surface
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Historical (1894): Holt calls for a mattress “firm but soft,” a very thin pillow, and covering that is not excessive. He suggests hair pillows in summer, and says nothing should be kept about the crib that cannot be washed.
Today: Outdated on pillows and soft bedding. Safe to Sleep says to use a sleep surface that is firm (it springs back quickly when pressed), flat, level and covered only with a fitted sheet. The AAP says to keep pillows and pillow-like toys, quilts, comforters, mattress toppers, non-fitted sheets, blankets, toys and bumper pads out of the sleep space, and not to use weighted sleep sacks, swaddles or other weighted objects on or near your baby. For warmth, dress your baby in layers or use a wearable blanket.
Where your baby sleeps
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Historical (1894): Holt says a child should not sleep in the same bed with its mother or nurse.
Today: The AAP agrees on bed sharing and recommends against it under any circumstances, including with twins. The AAP recommends room sharing for at least the first 6 months: your baby’s own sleep space in your room, close to your bed but not in it. Safe to Sleep says room sharing is safer than bed sharing and safer than putting baby in a separate room. If you bring your baby into your bed to feed or comfort, first clear away soft items and bedding, and put the baby back in their own sleep space when you are done. If you fall asleep, move the baby back as soon as you wake up. The AAP says the risk of sleep-related death is far higher when a baby sleeps with someone on a couch, soft armchair or cushion, and that bed sharing is especially risky if an adult has been drinking alcohol, used drugs or medicines that make it hard to wake, or is very tired.
Room temperature and overheating
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Historical (1894): Holt says the nursery should be kept near 68° F by day, never above 70° F, and that a window may be left open at night after the second month except in severe weather.
Today: The AAP warns that overheating can increase the risk of SIDS. A baby usually needs only one more layer than an adult would wear in the same room. Check for signs of overheating such as sweating.
Bedtime routines, night feeding and pacifiers
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Historical (1894): Holt says to put a baby to sleep at exactly the same time every day, to lay the baby in the crib awake, and that rocking is a useless habit. He says that by five months a baby should not be fed between 10 p.m. and 7 a.m.
Today: Partly outdated. Laying a baby down in their own safe sleep space is consistent with today’s guidance, but a fixed rule on night feeding is not. The CDC says to keep feeding your baby when they show signs of hunger and that most 6 to 12 month olds feed about 5 to 6 times in 24 hours. Ask your pediatrician about night feeding for your baby.
Historical (1894): Holt says sucking should not be allowed as a way to put children to sleep.
Today: Outdated. The AAP suggests offering a pacifier at nap time and bedtime because pacifiers help reduce the risk of SIDS, even if the pacifier falls out after the baby is asleep. If you breastfeed, wait until breastfeeding is going well. Safe to Sleep says not to coat a pacifier with anything, such as a sweet liquid or honey, and not to force it if your baby does not want it.
Historical (1894): Holt says soothing syrups or other drugs to make a baby sleep should never be given.
Today: Never give any medicine or sleep aid unless your pediatrician tells you to.
Smoke, sleep outdoors and tummy time
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Historical (1894): Holt says there is no real objection to an infant sleeping outdoors in a carriage.
Today: Wherever your baby sleeps, the same rules apply: on the back, on a firm, flat, level surface with nothing else in it. The AAP also says babies exposed to nicotine during pregnancy or after birth face a higher SIDS risk, especially when they sleep with an adult who smokes or vapes.
Today: The 1894 book does not mention tummy time. Safe to Sleep recommends plenty of tummy time while your baby is awake and someone is watching. Safe to Sleep also asks everyone who cares for your baby, including grandparents, sitters and child care providers, to learn safe sleep.
Car seats
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Today: The 1894 book has no travel advice. The AAP says all infants and toddlers should ride in a rear-facing car seat as long as possible, until they reach the top weight or height allowed by the seat maker. The CDC says rear-facing from birth until about age 2 to 4, with a harness, until the child reaches the seat’s limit.
Sources
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Reviewed November 22, 2026. The official pages control if guidance changes.
THIS IS FLORIDA is an independent informational resource and is not affiliated with a Florida government agency, the American Academy of Pediatrics or the publishers of the books listed. This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.