Feeding Your Baby | THIS IS FLORIDA
Breast milk, formula, how much and how often, solid foods, honey, cow’s milk and choking, with each 1894 point checked against today’s guidance.
Florida information in plain text. No need to ask AI.
What the 1894 book covers
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Part II of the 1894 first edition, Infant Feeding, is the longest part of the book. It covers nursing, home-mixed cow’s milk formulas, condensed milk and branded patent foods, bottles, feeding intervals, and diets up to age four. Every point below is labeled “Historical (1894)” and followed by “Today:” with current official guidance. No old formula recipe or amount from the book is repeated here, and none should be used.
Breast milk and how often to nurse
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Historical (1894): Holt puts mother’s milk first among infant foods. He says a newborn needs to nurse only four or five times a day for the first three days, then every two hours by day and twice at night, for no more than twenty minutes at a time. He stresses “regularity” and says a sleeping baby may be woken on schedule for a few days.
Today: Partly outdated. The CDC says a newborn may want to eat as often as every 1 to 3 hours in the first days, and that frequent feeding helps build milk supply. Over the following weeks, most babies who get only breast milk feed every 2 to 4 hours, and some cluster feed as often as every hour at times. The CDC agrees that some sleepy newborns need to be woken to feed. The AAP says most healthy, full-term babies can be fed on demand, by watching for hunger cues such as rooting, lip licking or hands to the mouth; crying is a late sign of hunger. Premature babies or babies with some medical conditions may need a schedule set by the pediatrician.
Today: The CDC and AAP recommend breast milk alone for about the first 6 months, then continuing to breastfeed while adding foods, to age 2 or beyond if you and your baby wish. The CDC says most breastfed babies should not be given formula in the first few days. If you worry your baby is not getting enough, ask a lactation consultant, your baby’s nurse or your pediatrician.
Infant formula
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Historical (1894): For bottle-fed babies, Holt gives home recipes that mix cow’s milk, skimmed “top milk,” barley water and sugar in amounts by age. He also discusses canned condensed milk and patent foods, which he says should be used only as temporary substitutes.
Today: Outdated and unsafe. Do not make any homemade formula. The FDA advises parents and caregivers not to make or feed homemade infant formula, because recipes have not been evaluated and may lack nutrients a baby needs. The CDC says to choose a commercial formula made especially for babies and recommends iron-fortified formula. Follow the CDC’s preparation and storage instructions and the directions on the container, and ask your pediatrician before you switch brands or types.
Today: The CDC says a formula-fed newborn can start with 1 to 2 ounces every 2 to 3 hours in the first days, with more if the baby shows hunger, and that most formula-fed newborns feed 8 to 12 times in 24 hours. Most babies 6 to 12 months old need formula or solid foods about 5 to 6 times in 24 hours, and need less formula as they eat more solids. Your pediatrician will tell you what is right for your baby.
Starting solid foods
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Historical (1894): Holt says that nothing besides breast milk or the bottle is usually given until about ten months, when a little beef juice or soft-boiled egg may be started. He then gives a long list of foods “forbidden” before age four, including tomatoes, bananas and most fruit in summer.
Today: Outdated. The CDC and AAP say most children can begin solid foods at about 6 months, and the CDC says starting before 4 months is not recommended. The AAP says to include foods that give iron and zinc, such as iron-fortified baby cereal or baby food made with meat, and that there is no evidence that waiting past 4 to 6 months to introduce foods such as eggs, peanut products or fish prevents food allergy. The CDC says that by 7 or 8 months a child can eat a variety of foods from different food groups, including vegetables, fruits, proteins and dairy without added sugars, such as yogurt.
Honey and cow’s milk
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Today: The 1894 book does not mention honey. The CDC says: do not give honey to a child younger than 12 months. Honey can cause a severe food poisoning called botulism. Do not add honey to your baby’s food, water, formula or pacifier.
Historical (1894): Holt treats diluted cow’s milk as the standard bottle food for infants, and makes milk “the basis of the diet,” about a quart a day, for children from eighteen months to four years.
Today: Outdated for babies. The CDC says to introduce whole cow’s milk at 12 months, but not before. Before 12 months, cow’s milk may put a baby at risk for intestinal bleeding, has too many proteins and minerals for a baby’s kidneys, and does not have the right nutrients. From 12 months, pasteurized, unsweetened whole milk can be part of a varied diet, but it is not a substitute for food.
Choking
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Historical (1894): Holt says grapes are objectionable “only on account of the seeds.” For a swallowed object, he says to feel in the throat with a finger and then give dry food such as bread.
Today: Outdated. The CDC lists uncut grapes, berries, cherries and melon balls as choking hazards, along with foods such as whole corn kernels, pieces of hard raw vegetables or fruit, whole or chopped nuts, spoonfuls of nut butter, hot dogs, and large chunks of meat or cheese. Cut food into small pieces or mash it. Have your child sit up in a high chair or other safe place to eat, not lying down, crawling, walking or riding in a car or stroller, and watch your child at all times while eating. Talk with your pediatrician about what to do if your child chokes.
Today: The AAP recommends that parents take a certified CPR and first aid course, and warns that button and coin batteries can also cause internal burns if swallowed. If you think your child swallowed a battery, a magnet, medicine or a chemical, call Poison Control at 1-800-222-1222. Call 911 if the child collapses, has a seizure, has trouble breathing or cannot be awakened.
Sources
This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.
Reviewed November 22, 2026. The official pages control if guidance changes.
- Internet Archive: The Care and Feeding of Children, L. Emmett Holt, 1894 first edition
- CDC: Breastfeeding
- CDC: How Much and How Often to Breastfeed
- AAP: How Often and How Much Should Your Baby Eat
- CDC: Choosing an Infant Formula
- CDC: How Much and How Often to Feed Infant Formula
- CDC: Infant Formula Preparation and Storage
- FDA: Do Not Make or Feed Homemade Infant Formula
- CDC: When, What, and How to Introduce Solid Foods
- AAP: Starting Solid Foods
- CDC: Foods and Drinks to Avoid or Limit
- CDC: Cow’s Milk and Milk Alternatives
- CDC: Choking Hazards
- AAP: Choking Prevention
- Poison Control (poison.org)
THIS IS FLORIDA is an independent informational resource and is not affiliated with a Florida government agency, the American Academy of Pediatrics or the publishers of the books listed. This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.