Florida Information · Learning Center

Crying and Colic | THIS IS FLORIDA

How much crying is normal, ways to soothe, colic, never shaking a baby, and when crying needs a call to the pediatrician.

Official-source review: November 22, 2026 · Independent Florida guide

Florida information in plain text. No need to ask AI.

Important: This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician. This chapter compares an 1894 book with current guidance. Never shake a baby. If you feel you might lose control, put your baby in a safe crib and step away. In an emergency, call 911. For a possible poisoning, call Poison Control at 1-800-222-1222.

What the 1894 book covers

This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.

Part III of the 1894 first edition has a section titled Cry, and a short entry on colic under nursery medicine. Each point below is labeled “Historical (1894)” and followed by “Today:” with guidance from the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the CDC.

How much crying is normal

This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.

Historical (1894): Holt says 15 to 30 minutes of strong crying a day is normal for a very young baby, and calls it “the baby’s exercise,” needed to expand the lungs.
Today: The lung reasoning is outdated, but crying is expected. The AAP says regular fussing usually peaks at about 3 hours a day by 6 weeks of age, then drops to 1 or 2 hours a day by 3 to 4 months. The CDC says crying, including long periods of crying that cannot be soothed, is normal behavior in infants and gets better as the child grows.

Reading the cry

This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.

Historical (1894): Holt describes cries of pain, hunger, temper, illness and habit, and says the cry of hunger is a continuous, fretful cry.
Today: The AAP says crying is a late sign of hunger and suggests watching for earlier cues, such as rooting, lip licking, hands to the mouth or fussiness. The AAP lists other reasons for crying, such as being sick, overstimulated or bored, and suggests quietly singing, humming or going for a walk.

Soothing a crying baby

This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.

Historical (1894): Holt says a baby who cries from temper or to be indulged should simply be left to “cry it out,” and calls rocking a useless habit.
Today: Outdated. The AAP colic page suggests walking your baby in a carrier, rocking, steady sounds such as a fan or white noise, swaddling in a large, thin blanket, a pacifier, or laying your baby tummy-down across your knees while awake and gently rubbing the back. The AAP also says never to place a baby on top of a running washer or dryer. The CDC suggests swaddling, holding your baby against your bare skin, a pacifier, gentle rocking, singing or talking softly, and a stroller walk or a drive. Any time your baby falls asleep, place them in their own crib on their back.

Colic

This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.

Historical (1894): For colic, the book suggests a hot-water bag or hot flannel, and if that fails, an enema with turpentine, or a little gin or brandy for gas.
Today: Outdated and unsafe. Never give a baby alcohol, turpentine or any old home remedy, and this page does not repeat any of those amounts. The AAP says about one-fifth of babies develop colic, usually between the second and fourth weeks, with crying that cannot be soothed, often with legs pulled up and gas. Talk with your pediatrician first to make sure the crying is not caused by a medical problem such as a hernia or another illness. If you are nursing, the AAP says your pediatrician may suggest removing one food at a time from your own diet, and expecting about 2 weeks to see a change. If your baby takes formula, ask your pediatrician whether a different formula would help. Colic gets better as babies mature.

Never shake a baby

This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.

Today: The 1894 book does not discuss shaking. The CDC says abusive head trauma, caused by violent shaking or blunt impact, is a leading cause of child abuse deaths in children under five, and that babies younger than 1 year old are at particular risk. Shaking, throwing or hitting a baby is never the right response to crying. The AAP says it is never safe to shake, throw, hit, slam or jerk any child.

Today: If you feel upset, the CDC says to put the baby in a safe place, walk away to calm down, and check on the baby every 5 to 10 minutes. The AAP suggests a crib or playpen without blankets or stuffed animals, and letting your baby cry alone for about 10 to 15 minutes while you take a deep breath. Call a friend, relative, neighbor, parent helpline or your child’s doctor for support. The CDC also says never to leave your baby with anyone who is easily irritated, has a temper or a history of violence.

When crying needs a call

This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.

Historical (1894): Holt says an abnormal cry is a moaning, worrying or feeble whine, and that bad sleep is an early sign of illness.
Today: Call your pediatrician if crying seems different or will not stop. The AAP says to check your baby’s temperature: if your baby is younger than 2 months and has a fever, call the doctor right away. The AAP fever page says to call right away if a baby younger than 3 months (12 weeks) has a temperature of 100.4° F (38.0° C) or higher. The AAP also says to call your pediatrician if your baby is fussy after feeding, spits up or vomits a lot, or is losing weight or not gaining. The CDC says that if a baby will not stop crying, check for signs of illness and call the doctor if you think the child is sick.

Today: Caring for a crying baby is hard. The AAP says to let your own doctor know if you feel depressed or are having trouble with your emotions. The CDC lists the National Maternal Mental Health Hotline: call or text 1-833-852-6262, free, confidential and open 24/7. In a crisis, call or text 988. See the postpartum care chapter of this book.

Sources

This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.

Reviewed November 22, 2026. The official pages control if guidance changes.

  1. Internet Archive: The Care and Feeding of Children, L. Emmett Holt, 1894 first edition
  2. AAP: Colic Relief Tips for Parents
  3. AAP: Calming a Fussy Baby
  4. AAP: Responding to Your Baby’s Cries
  5. AAP: How Often and How Much Should Your Baby Eat
  6. CDC: About Abusive Head Trauma
  7. AAP: Fever, When to Call the Pediatrician
  8. AAP: A Parent’s Guide to Safe Sleep

THIS IS FLORIDA is an independent informational resource and is not affiliated with a Florida government agency, the American Academy of Pediatrics or the publishers of the books listed. This is not medical advice. Check with your pediatrician.