Florida Information · Ocean and coast

Is It Really Florida Seafood? Mislabeling Laws and How to Report It

What Florida statutes, FDA, and USDA say about honest seafood labels, how substitution happens, and which agency to call when something seems wrong.

Official-source review: November 20, 2026 · Independent Florida guide

Florida information in plain text. No need to ask AI.

Free to read · No account needed · Print or save as PDF

2

Check the label rules

Learn the difference between a useful question and evidence of a violation.

Understand origin labels
Important: Statutes, federal guidance, and agency contact details can change. The statute text quoted here is from the 2026 Florida Statutes on the Florida Senate site; use the linked official text for any legal question. This page is general information, not legal, navigation, or food-safety advice.

Quick answer

Selling one fish under the name of another is prohibited under Florida law, and FDA says it is prohibited in interstate commerce under federal law. In stores and markets, Florida's food law treats a food as misbranded if its labeling is false or misleading or if it is offered for sale under the name of another food, and selling misbranded food is a prohibited act. In restaurants, a separate Florida statute makes knowing and willful misrepresentation of a food's identity a second-degree misdemeanor. FDACS says a grouper bearing the Fresh From Florida logo is required by law to be from Florida. To report suspected mislabeling, FDACS lists (850) 245-5595 for retail markets and grocery stores and the Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) at (850) 487-1395 for restaurants.

What seafood mislabeling looks like

FDA describes economic fraud in seafood as substituting a less expensive species for a more expensive one, and says this is prohibited in interstate commerce under the misbranding section of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, which deems a food misbranded if it is offered for sale under the name of another food. FDA's published examples include various snappers or rockfish sold as red snapper, mako shark sold as swordfish, black drum sold as red drum, imported crabmeat sold as blue crabmeat, and farm-raised salmon sold as wild-caught salmon.

FDACS says Florida grouper, because of its limited supply and relatively high price, has been a target, with lesser-value species such as basa, swai, sutchi, or tra catfish substituted. Mislabeling can also involve weight, origin, or whether a product is wild or farmed.

Florida law for stores, markets, and food sellers

Chapter 500 of the Florida Statutes is the Florida Food Safety Act. Section 500.11(1) says a food is deemed misbranded, among other things, "(a) If its labeling is false or misleading in any particular" and "(b) If it is offered for sale under the name of another food." It also covers imitation foods that are not labeled with the word "imitation" and the name of the food imitated, and packaged food that lacks an accurate statement of the quantity of contents.

Section 500.04 lists prohibited acts, including "(1) The manufacture, sale or delivery, holding or offering for sale of any food that is adulterated or misbranded" and "(2) The adulteration or misbranding of any food." It also prohibits removing or altering labeling while a food is held for sale if that results in misbranding.

Florida law for restaurants

Section 509.292 sits in the chapter of the Florida Statutes on lodging and food service establishments. It says an operator "may not knowingly and willfully misrepresent the identity of any food or food product to any of the patrons of such establishment." Under the statute, identity is misrepresented if the description is false or misleading in any particular, if the food is served, sold, or distributed under the name of another food, or if it is represented as a food that does not conform to a definition of identity and standard of quality established by custom and usage. Subsection (3) says a person who violates the section is guilty of a misdemeanor of the second degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082 or s. 775.083.

FDACS links this statute on its seafood mislabeling page and directs restaurant complaints to DBPR.

"Florida grouper" and the Fresh From Florida logo

FDACS advises diners and shoppers to look for a label on the menu or at the store. It says that if grouper bears the Fresh From Florida logo, the law requires the grouper to be from Florida, and that grouper from another country can be labeled as "grouper" but not as "Florida grouper." FDACS describes grouper as a lean, white-flesh fish, usually sold as thick fillets with a firm texture, and suggests dealing with merchants you trust.

Seafood names and the FDA Seafood List

FDA publishes The Seafood List, guidance to help industry choose acceptable market names, common names, and scientific names for seafood sold in the United States. FDA states that its guidance documents describe its current thinking and are recommendations unless specific statutory or regulatory requirements are cited. In practice, a name on a label or menu that does not match FDA's acceptable market name for that species is a reason to ask questions, and the misbranding law still applies whether or not a seller consults the list.

Country-of-origin labels

USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service (AMS) enforces Country of Origin Labeling (COOL). AMS lists wild-caught and farm-raised fish and shellfish as covered commodities, and its retail reviews check that origin declarations are legible and conspicuous and that the method of production for fish and shellfish is properly declared. Suppliers and retailers must keep records supporting origin claims for one year.

COOL has limits. AMS says it does not extend to processed foods or multi-ingredient items, and that hotels, restaurants, food stands, and other sellers of ready-to-eat foods are exempt. It applies to retailers subject to licensing under the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act, such as full-line grocery stores, supermarkets, and warehouse clubs.

Ice glaze and package weight

FDACS also flags frozen seafood sold with an ice coating, called a glaze, especially shrimp and lobster tails. It says the net weight on the package must be the unglazed weight of the product, and that if the glaze is excessive and the customer is charged for extra ice, the product is mislabeled. If you suspect a problem, keep the package and receipt and weigh the product after rinsing off only the glaze.

Questions worth asking, not proof of fraud

An unusually low price, vague name or unexpected appearance can justify a question. It does not establish that a business has broken the law. Frozen or imported fish can be sold lawfully when described accurately, and peak availability is not the same as a legal fishing season.

Ask for the species, origin, whether it was previously frozen and the price basis. Country-of-origin labeling has exemptions, including restaurants and some foods; a missing restaurant origin label alone does not prove a COOL violation. Preserve what the seller actually represented and let the appropriate agency assess a complaint.

How to report it

Write down the business name and address, the date, the item name as shown on the label or menu, the price, and what made you suspicious. Keep receipts, packaging, and photos.

Printable seafood buyer checklist

Seller, location and date: ____________________________

Item name and origin stated: ____________________________

Price, quantity and receipt number: ____________________________

Question asked and seller’s response: ____________________________

Agency contacted and reference number: ____________________________

Where to report a seafood concern

Choose the route for the seller or label issue
ConcernWhere to startWhat to keep
Retail seafood market or grocery storeFDACS reporting guidance · 850-245-5595Receipt, package, label and seller details.
Restaurant menu or served productFDACS page with the DBPR complaint link · 850-487-1395Menu wording, receipt, date and location.
Covered grocery-store origin labelUSDA COOL complaint portal linkLabel or display photo and store details.
FDA-regulated product problemFDA’s current reporting routes · 1-888-INFO-FDAPackage identifiers and a factual account of the problem.

Official sources and current guidance

Reviewed November 20, 2026. These links control if a rule, season, or contact number changes.

  1. Florida Statutes 500.11: Food deemed misbranded (2026)
  2. Florida Statutes 500.04: Prohibited acts (2026)
  3. Florida Statutes 509.292: Misrepresenting food or food product; penalty (2026)
  4. FDACS: Mislabeling seafood products is illegal
  5. FDA: Seafood species substitution and economic fraud
  6. FDA: Guidance for industry, The Seafood List
  7. USDA AMS: Country of Origin Labeling (COOL)
  8. FDA: How to report a problem by phone

THIS IS FLORIDA is an independent informational resource and is not affiliated with a Florida government agency. Confirm current details with the responsible agency before acting.