This Is Florida ยท History and mysteries
Florida and the Bermuda Triangle: the facts, the myths, and the legends
The most famous Bermuda Triangle story starts in Florida. On a December afternoon in 1945, five Navy planes took off from Fort Lauderdale and were never seen again. Here's what the official record says happened, what NOAA says about the Triangle itself, the science behind the dangers, and the myths that grew around them.
The short answer
NOAA says there is no evidence that mysterious disappearances happen more often in the Bermuda Triangle than in any other large, well-traveled area of the ocean. It says storms, the Gulf Stream, shallow water, and human error explain many, if not most, of the losses. The Navy and Coast Guard, NOAA reports, say there are no supernatural explanations.
The losses were real, though, and some have never been solved. That's where the legends come from.
Where is the Bermuda Triangle?
- Officially, nowhere. NOAA says no official maps mark its boundaries, and the U.S. Board on Geographic Names doesn't recognize the name or keep a file on the area.
- Generally: a region in the western part of the North Atlantic, where ships, planes, and people are alleged to have vanished.
- In popular telling: it's usually drawn as a triangle with one corner in South Florida, one at Bermuda, and one at Puerto Rico. That's a popular description, not an official one.
Florida's part in the story
| Connection | What the source says |
|---|---|
| Flight 19 | The planes took off from Fort Lauderdale Naval Air Station on December 5, 1945, according to the National Archives article "The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19" (2017) |
| The flight leader | He had been based at Miami Naval Air Station and knew the area, and he believed he was over the Florida Keys when he was actually well northeast of Fort Lauderdale, per the National Archives article "The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19" (2017) |
| The Gulf Stream | It moves north along the coast of Florida, then turns east off North Carolina |
| Hurricanes | Most Atlantic tropical storms and hurricanes pass through the Triangle, and hurricane season runs June 1 to November 30 |
Flight 19: what the record shows
This timeline comes from the National Archives article "The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19" (2017), written by archivists at the National Archives at Fort Worth, which holds the Navy's investigation records and correspondence. You can see the flight's navigation map, National Archives ID 73985447.
| Time, Dec. 5, 1945 | What happened |
|---|---|
| Afternoon | Instructor pilot Lt. Charles C. Taylor, 28, with combat experience and 2,500 flight hours, is assigned Navigation Problem #1: east from Fort Lauderdale, a practice bombing run at Hen and Chicken Shoals north of Bimini, then north over Grand Bahama, then southwest back to base. About 316 miles and 2 hours 40 minutes. |
| 2:10 p.m. | Five Grumman Avengers with 14 sailors and Marines leave Fort Lauderdale Naval Air Station. |
| About 3 p.m. | The bombing run is complete. |
| 3:40 p.m. | First sign of trouble. One pilot radios that they must have gotten lost after the last turn. |
| Minutes later | Taylor radios that both his compasses are out, and that he's sure he's in the Keys but doesn't know how to get back. |
| Next two hours | The flight keeps changing direction as pilots disagree. Taylor is the instructor, but the ranking officer is Capt. Edward Powers, USMC. |
| 5:30 p.m. | The sun has set, the weather is getting worse, and fuel is critically low. Search and rescue launches. |
| 7:04 p.m. | Last transmission heard. Taylor tells the planes to close up and that they'll all ditch together when the first one gets low on fuel. |
| About 7:30 p.m. | The first rescue aircraft reaches the suspected area and finds overcast skies, showers, 25 to 30 knot winds, and very rough seas. There's no sign of Flight 19. |
The Navy's conclusion
The National Archives article "The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19" (2017) says the Navy concluded the flight got lost through pilot error, with Lieutenant Taylor "uncertain as to in what position lay the Peninsula of Florida," forcing a ditching in darkness and poor weather. No wreckage or bodies were ever recovered. The National Archives also holds a Navy request for information from December 28, 1945.
The aircraft type was a widely used Navy torpedo bomber. The National Park Service notes it flew in every theater of World War II.
The rescue plane that never came back
About 20 minutes after the first rescue aircraft arrived, the National Archives article "The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19" (2017) says, one of the many search planes exploded in the air, killing the 13 men aboard. The Navy concluded a faulty fuel system caused it. Altogether, the night cost 27 lives.
USS Cyclops, 1918
This is the other case people bring up most often. These facts come from the National Archives article "The Mysterious Disappearance of the USS Cyclops (AC-4)" (2021), which features the ship's original plans (National Archives ID 53483983).
| Fact | What the record says |
|---|---|
| The ship | A Navy collier, a cargo ship built to carry coal, launched in May 1910 in Philadelphia |
| The cargo | Manganese ore, much denser than coal |
| Warning signs | Before leaving Rio de Janeiro, it was reported overloaded and with a cracked cylinder |
| The route | Rio de Janeiro to Salvador, Brazil, then toward Baltimore, with an unscheduled stop in Barbados because it was overloaded |
| The loss | It left Barbados and was never seen again, in March 1918, with all hands, over 200 sailors. No debris was ever recovered, and no distress call was heard. |
| Theories | Sunk by the German Navy, a cargo that shifted and caused it to list, a sudden explosion, or the Bermuda Triangle |
| The Navy's answer | "Her loss remains unknown" |
| Sister ships | The USS Nereus and USS Proteus also disappeared with all hands in the Atlantic |
The real dangers, according to NOAA
| Danger | What NOAA says |
|---|---|
| Storms | Most Atlantic tropical storms and hurricanes pass through the Triangle, and before better forecasting they claimed many ships |
| The Gulf Stream | Can cause rapid, sometimes violent, weather changes. It averages about 4 mph, with maximum speeds typically about 5.6 mph near the surface, and carries more water than all the world's rivers combined. |
| Shallow water | The many Caribbean islands create shallow areas that are treacherous for navigation |
| Compass | Some evidence that a magnetic compass sometimes points toward true north there, instead of magnetic north |
| Human error | NOAA reports the Navy and Coast Guard's view that nature and human fallibility outdo science fiction |
The myths and legends
NOAA lists the popular explanations itself. Here's how it describes them:
| Legend | How NOAA describes it |
|---|---|
| Aliens capturing people for study | Among the whimsical ideas |
| The lost continent of Atlantis | Among the whimsical ideas |
| Vortices pulling things into other dimensions | Among the whimsical ideas |
| Methane gas erupting from the seafloor | More grounded in science, if not in evidence. NOAA calls it oceanic flatulence. |
| Disrupted magnetic fields | More grounded in science, if not in evidence |
The National Archives article "The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19" (2017) adds sea monsters and whirlpools to the list, and says books, articles, and films have turned Flight 19 into myth. Its view is that the myths help explain why the plain facts "leave something in the mind that does not satisfy."
Myth or record?
| What people say | What the record shows | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Flight 19 vanished in perfect weather | By sunset, weather was deteriorating. Rescuers found 25 to 30 knot winds and very rough seas. | the National Archives article "The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19" (2017) |
| Their instruments went haywire mysteriously | The leader said his compasses were out, and the Navy concluded the flight got lost through pilot error | the National Archives article "The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19" (2017) |
| Flight 19 came back | Only in the 1977 film Close Encounters of the Third Kind. The planes and men were never found. | the National Archives article "The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19" (2017) |
| Disappearances happen more there than anywhere | No evidence they happen more often than in any other large, well-traveled ocean area | NOAA |
| It's an official danger zone | No official boundaries, and not a recognized name | NOAA |
| Something supernatural sank the Cyclops | The cause is unknown. It was overloaded with dense ore and had a reported mechanical problem. | the National Archives article "The Mysterious Disappearance of the USS Cyclops (AC-4)" (2021) |
Boating those waters today
The basics before you head out:
- Check the marine forecast before you go. The National Weather Service publishes South Florida coastal waters forecasts.
- Know hurricane season: June 1 to November 30.
- Respect the Gulf Stream. NOAA says it can change the weather fast.
- Carry the required gear. FWC lists required safety equipment by boat size.
- Tell someone your plan, including where you're going and when you'll be back. That last tip is ours.
Where sources differ
| Question | One source | Another source |
|---|---|---|
| How many were aboard the Cyclops | The National Archives article "The Mysterious Disappearance of the USS Cyclops (AC-4)" (2021): over 200 sailors. | A Library of Congress article on a 1921 ghost ship case: nearly 300 people. Counts vary. Both figures are shown. |
| Why Flight 19 was lost | The National Archives article "The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19" (2017): the Navy concluded pilot error. | The Navy's own history pages could not be opened to check whether later reviews changed that wording. See the note below. |
The Naval History and Heritage Command site and the Coast Guard history site did not open for this check, so they are not used here. Both agencies have their own pages on these cases. The page stays with NOAA and the National Archives.
Questions people ask
Is the Bermuda Triangle real?
As a place name, not officially. NOAA says no official maps mark its boundaries and the U.S. Board on Geographic Names does not recognize it. NOAA also says there is no evidence that mysterious disappearances happen more often there than in any other large, well-traveled area of the ocean.
Is Florida part of the Bermuda Triangle?
There are no official boundaries, so there's no official answer. NOAA places it in the western part of the North Atlantic, and popular versions are usually drawn with one corner in South Florida. Florida's biggest tie is Flight 19, which took off from Fort Lauderdale in 1945.
What happened to Flight 19?
On December 5, 1945, five Navy Avenger aircraft with 14 sailors and Marines left Fort Lauderdale Naval Air Station on a training flight and never returned. The National Archives says Navy records show the flight got lost, ran low on fuel in darkness and bad weather, and had to ditch. The Navy concluded it was pilot error. No wreckage or bodies were ever recovered.
What happened to the rescue plane that searched for Flight 19?
One of the many search aircraft exploded in the air that night, killing the 13 men aboard. The National Archives says the Navy blamed a faulty fuel system.
Where did Flight 19 take off from?
Fort Lauderdale Naval Air Station, at 2:10 p.m. on December 5, 1945.
What was the USS Cyclops?
A Navy collier, a cargo ship built to carry coal, which vanished with all hands in March 1918 after leaving Barbados for Baltimore. It was carrying heavy manganese ore and had been reported overloaded. No wreckage was ever found, and the Navy says the cause remains unknown.
Why do ships and planes disappear in the Bermuda Triangle?
NOAA says environmental factors could explain many, if not most, disappearances. Most Atlantic tropical storms and hurricanes pass through the area, the Gulf Stream can cause rapid and sometimes violent weather changes, and shallow water around many islands is hard to navigate.
Do compasses go crazy in the Bermuda Triangle?
NOAA says there is some evidence that a magnetic compass sometimes points toward true north there, instead of magnetic north. That's a navigation factor, not a supernatural one.
What does the Coast Guard say about the Bermuda Triangle?
NOAA reports that the Navy and Coast Guard say there are no supernatural explanations for disasters at sea, and that nature and human error explain them.
How fast is the Gulf Stream off Florida?
NOAA says it moves north along the coast of Florida, averaging about 4 miles per hour, with maximum speeds typically about 5.6 miles per hour near the surface.
When is hurricane season?
The Atlantic hurricane season runs from June 1 to November 30, according to the National Hurricane Center.
Was Flight 19 in Close Encounters of the Third Kind?
In the movie, yes. The National Archives notes that the 1977 film showed Flight 19 reappearing, neither aged nor damaged. That's fiction. In the real record, the planes and men were never found.
Sources
- NOAA: What is the Bermuda Triangle?, How fast is the Gulf Stream?, National Hurricane Center climatology, South Florida marine forecast
- U.S. Board on Geographic Names
- National Archives: "Uncertain as to in what position lay the Peninsula of Florida: The Official Record and the Loss of Flight 19," National Archives at Fort Worth staff, October 16, 2017; "Her loss remains unknown: The Mysterious Disappearance of the USS Cyclops (AC-4)," Cartographic Branch, October 28, 2021; catalog records 73985447, 73985451, and 53483983
- Library of Congress: "The Mysterious Disappearance of Ghost Ship Carroll A. Deering's Crew," 2023
- National Park Service: TBM-3E Avenger
- FWC: boating safety equipment
The National Archives and Library of Congress articles are named, not linked. Search their titles to find them.
More on the water: hurricane costs, beach warning flags, and boating laws.