Family owned Old Town pasta cafe with fresh pasta made daily, open since 1989 · Key West, Florida
Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe
Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe is a family owned Italian restaurant at 900 Southard Street, on a tree lined street in the heart of Old Town Key West. It has welcomed guests since 1989.
Contact
Address900 Southard Street
Key West, Florida 33040
Phone(305) 294-2469
Websitemangia-mangia.com
Official website · Info from the business's own website, checked Nov 20, 2026
About
Owner and manager Heather "Sunny" Weather leads the restaurant, with her husband Michael and a longtime team. Many staff members have worked there for nearly 20 years. Fresh pasta is made by hand every day. The kitchen offers hearty semolina wheat pastas along with gluten free and egg free choices. Every pasta is paired with house made sauces. The menu blends classic Italian cooking with fresh local seafood and a tropical Key West twist. Key lime pie is a house favorite for dessert. Guests can dine in the cozy dining room or in an outdoor garden lit by twinkling lights. The restaurant supports the local community, schools and artists. It even set aside a gallery space to show the work of local artists. Heather shares recipes and the stories behind the dishes on the restaurant's blog.
In this area — Key West, Florida
More independent Florida listings in Key West:
- Schooner Wharf Bar · Open air harbor bar with live music and local seafood on the Historic Harbor Walk at the foot of Wil
- Martin's Key West · Steak and lobster restaurant on Duval Street in Key West from chef Martin Busam, blending German coo
- Azur Restaurant · Mediterranean restaurant on Grinnell Street in Key West from chefs and co owners Michael Mosi and Dr
- Date & Thyme · Organic cafe and natural market in Key West, owned by Bob and Lindsey Finer since 2021
- Key West Cakes · Family owned specialty bakery for custom and wedding cakes, started in 2001 by Paul and his partner
Explore more around Key West: Key West City Guide · All Key West Businesses · Florida Beaches · Florida State Parks · Florida Weather