Family owned specialty bakery for custom and wedding cakes, started in 2001 by Paul and his partner · Key West, Florida
Key West Cakes
Key West Cakes is a family owned specialty bakery in Key West. It began in 2001 with Paul's passion for baking, creativity and making people smile.
Contact
Address2510 North Roosevelt Boulevard
Key West, Florida 33040
Phone(305) 296-4162
Websitekeywestcakes.com
Official website · Info from the business's own website, checked Nov 20, 2026
About
Paul and his partner, Steven, have spent a quarter century running the bakery. For many years the bakery's home was on White Street. In its 25th year, the bakery moved into a new permanent home at 2510 North Roosevelt Boulevard. The bakery makes custom cakes, wedding cakes, cupcakes and other sweet treats for locals and visitors. Wedding planning site The Knot has recognized the bakery in its wedding honors, voted on by couples who held Key West weddings. Couples planning a wedding can book one complimentary tasting for two to three people. Tastings are by appointment. Wedding cake orders are secured with a deposit, and details can still be changed afterward. The team works to match custom colors for each event. Tasting appointments can be set up by phone.
In this area — Key West, Florida
More independent Florida listings in Key West:
- Schooner Wharf Bar · Open air harbor bar with live music and local seafood on the Historic Harbor Walk at the foot of Wil
- Martin's Key West · Steak and lobster restaurant on Duval Street in Key West from chef Martin Busam, blending German coo
- Azur Restaurant · Mediterranean restaurant on Grinnell Street in Key West from chefs and co owners Michael Mosi and Dr
- Date & Thyme · Organic cafe and natural market in Key West, owned by Bob and Lindsey Finer since 2021
- 5 Brothers · Third generation Cuban coffee and sandwich shop in an Old Town corner store since 1978
Explore more around Key West: Key West City Guide · All Key West Businesses · Florida Beaches · Florida State Parks · Florida Weather