Third generation Cuban coffee and sandwich shop in an Old Town corner store since 1978 · Key West, Florida
5 Brothers
5 Brothers is a family run Cuban coffee and sandwich shop at 930 Southard Street in Old Town Key West. In 1978 Heriberto Paez and his four brothers opened a neighborhood grocery in a vintage corner store built in 1933.
Contact
Address930 Southard Street
Key West, Florida 33040
Phone(305) 296-5205
Website5brotherskeywest.com
Official website · Info from the business's own website, checked Nov 20, 2026
About
Over the decades locals came in for Cuban coffee, pressed sandwiches and conversation. The shop grew into a daily gathering place in Old Town life. In 1997 the business passed to the next generation, Heriberto "Pepe" Paez Jr. and Maribel. Pepe guided the shop from a traditional corner grocery into a daily home for coffee, food and conversation. Today a third generation carries the legacy forward. Francheska, called Fran, is the granddaughter of Heriberto Paez and runs the shop. Dan is co-owner alongside Fran and handles the back of house. The counter serves cortaditos, café con leche, Cuban sandwiches, soups and Fran's specials. Lattes are made too for guests who prefer them. Locals from around the island and travelers line up at the shop. Merchandise is sold, and orders can be placed online.
In this area — Key West, Florida
More independent Florida listings in Key West:
- Schooner Wharf Bar · Open air harbor bar with live music and local seafood on the Historic Harbor Walk at the foot of Wil
- Martin's Key West · Steak and lobster restaurant on Duval Street in Key West from chef Martin Busam, blending German coo
- Azur Restaurant · Mediterranean restaurant on Grinnell Street in Key West from chefs and co owners Michael Mosi and Dr
- Date & Thyme · Organic cafe and natural market in Key West, owned by Bob and Lindsey Finer since 2021
- Key West Cakes · Family owned specialty bakery for custom and wedding cakes, started in 2001 by Paul and his partner
Explore more around Key West: Key West City Guide · All Key West Businesses · Florida Beaches · Florida State Parks · Florida Weather