Full service scratch bakery · Lady Lake, Florida
Red Rooster Cookie Jar
Red Rooster Cookie Jar is a local, full service scratch bakery at 107 East Lady Lake Boulevard in Lady Lake, serving The Villages, Lady Lake and the surrounding area. The bakery says it is more than just a cookie jar, offering a wide range of baked goods made from scratch.
Contact
Address107 East Lady Lake Blvd.
32159
Phone(352) 204-0201
Websiterrcookiejar.com
Official website · Info from the business's own website, checked Nov 20, 2026
About
Owner Yvonne Conti O'Brien has run the Red Rooster Cookie Jar since 2018, bringing more than 30 years of experience in entrepreneurship and education to the business. The bakery says its first ingredient is always love, and that it uses fresh ingredients from local businesses and farmers in its recipes. The bakery offers cookies, cinnamon rolls and seasonal treats, along with a cookie of the week calendar, holiday preorders and items such as Benny Bites and Nibbles Nuggets. It also handles corporate gifting, parties and events, and offers local delivery in The Villages, Lady Lake and nearby communities. A loyalty program is available for online orders. The team describes themselves as residents of The Villages and neighbors in the community, not just a cookie shop. They say they want every guest to feel like they are visiting family when they walk through the door, and that the staff is committed to making each visit a good one. The bakery has been featured in a regional magazine's Inspiring Stories section for its role as a local change maker. Updates on new flavors and specials are shared through the bakery's mailing list. The listed phone number is (352) 204-0201.
In this area — Lady Lake, Florida
More independent Florida listings in Lady Lake:
- Ollie's Auto and Tire · Owner run auto repair and tire shop serving Lady Lake and The Villages
- Goneys Nursery and Landscaping · Family nursery and landscaping company with plants, palms, design, hardscapes and water features in
- Harbor Hills Country Club · Golf club
- OakWood Smokehouse & Grill Lady Lake · Restaurant
- Village Veterinarian · Veterinary clinic
Explore more around Lady Lake: Lady Lake City Guide · All Lady Lake Businesses · Florida Beaches · Florida State Parks · Florida Weather