THIS IS FLORIDA

Italian restaurant and pizzeria on Tamiami Trail in Punta Gorda, opened in 1983 by owner Diane Caput · Punta Gorda, Florida

Old Monty's

Old Monty's is an Italian restaurant and pizzeria at 2515 Tamiami Trail in Punta Gorda. It opened in October 1983 as the first authentic Italian restaurant in Punta Gorda.

Contact

Address2515 Tamiami Trail
Punta Gorda, Florida 33950

View address on map

Phone(941) 637-0008

Websiteoldmontys.com

Official website · Info from the business's own website, checked Nov 20, 2026

Open in Google Maps

About

Owner Diane Caputo has always treated her guests like family and wanted every meal to feel like home. On August 13, 2004, Hurricane Charley destroyed the original building. Monty's reopened months later in a shopping center across the street, but under new hands while Diane cared for her father and her own health. Customers felt it was not the same, and in mid 2007 Diane took the business back. She renamed it Old Monty's and brought back the old recipes and the original menu. She then rebuilt the restaurant at its original location. In 2009 Diane received the Southwest Florida Blue Chip Community Business honor for small business owners who overcame adversity. Everything is made from scratch, including baked dishes and salads, along with the pizza that put Monty's on the map. Gluten free items have been offered since 2009. The family also caters events, on the premises or off site. Guests can dine in or call ahead for pickup and carryout.

In this area — Punta Gorda, Florida

More independent Florida listings in Punta Gorda: