Family owned bakery · Anna Maria, Florida
Hometown Desserts
Hometown Desserts is a family owned bakery at 507 Pine Avenue in Anna Maria. It bakes cakes, pies, cheesecakes, brownies and custom treats for all kinds of occasions.
Contact
Address507 Pine Avenue
Anna Maria, Florida 34216
Websitehometowndesserts.com
Official website · Info from the business's own website, checked Nov 20, 2026
About
The bakery's official pages say Hometown Desserts began as a home based business in 2007, with roots going back more than 50 years to owner Cindy Tutterow's childhood in a family of southern women who loved to cook. As a child, Cindy spent many days standing on a chair at the kitchen counter, watching her mother and grandmothers make meals, and those times shaped her love of homemade treats. The bakery opened a retail storefront on Anna Maria Island in 2012 and added a second location in Bradenton in 2016. The star of the bakery is its Key Lime Coconut cake, which uses tropical ingredients. Custom creations are available for birthdays, anniversaries and graduations, including custom cakes, cookies and cake pops, and the bakery makes wedding cakes for island beach ceremonies. It can print edible logos and messages on cookies and cupcakes for corporate events and goody bags. Treats from Hometown Desserts are also served at many local restaurants. The bakery describes itself as being in the happiness business.
In this area — Anna Maria, Florida
More independent Florida listings in Anna Maria:
- Anna Maria General Store · General store, deli and bakery
- Ginny & Jane E's Cafe and Coastal Store · Cafe, bakery and coastal gift store
- gRub Tropical BBQ · Island-style barbecue restaurant
- Anna Maria Island Historical Society Museum · Museum
- The Waterfront Restaurant · Restaurant
Explore more around Anna Maria: Anna Maria City Guide · All Anna Maria Businesses · Florida Beaches · Florida State Parks · Florida Weather