Bagel, coffee and sandwich shop · Big Pine Key, Florida
Bagel Island Coffee
Bagel Island Coffee is a coffee, bagel and sandwich shop at 205 Key Deer Blvd in the Big Pine Shopping Center on Big Pine Key. The shop makes New York style bagels fresh every day and serves a full breakfast and lunch menu.
Contact
Address205 Key Deer Blvd
Big Pine Key, Florida 33043
Phone(305) 872 9912
Websitebagelislandcoffee.com
Official website · Info from the business's own website, checked Nov 20, 2026
About
For breakfast, guests can choose from fresh bagels, pastries, croissants and sweets along with hot breakfast dishes. Lunch includes sandwiches and weekday lunch specials, making the shop a convenient stop on Big Pine Key. The coffee menu includes real Cuban coffee, cappuccino, Americano, cafe con leche and teas, with dozens of flavors to choose from. Customers can also take flavored coffee home, including Inbru, a coffee flavoring made from rice hulls infused with aromatics and essential oils that is mixed with ground coffee at home. Bagel Island thanks local customers for spending their mornings at the shop. The full menu is available on the website, and visitors to Big Pine Key can stop in for coffee, a bagel or lunch.
In this area — Big Pine Key, Florida
More independent Florida listings in Big Pine Key:
- National Key Deer Refuge Nature Center · Free nature center for the Florida Keys wildlife refuges
- Old Wooden Bridge Resort and Marina · Resort and marina
- Good Food Conspiracy · Natural foods market and cafe
- No Name Pub · Restaurant and pub
- Blue Hole, National Key Deer Refuge · Wildlife observation area
Explore more around Big Pine Key: Big Pine Key City Guide · All Big Pine Key Businesses · Florida Beaches · Florida State Parks · Florida Weather